I'm just back from the
Festivaletteratura, Italy's largest literary festival and what may soon become a required stop for anyone who wants to bookend their summers between the Hay festival and a trip to Italy. Like Hay, it's held in an impossibly gorgeous old town (
Mantova). But because Italian bookstores are dense with translated work -- the children's author Bianca Pitzorno estimated to me that roughly 70% of their bestsellers are foreign translations -- it means that there's a very noticeable international presence among the authors there. Aside from yours truly, David Sedaris, Julia Kristeva, and Jasper Fforde were all in town for it too.
So, really: you should go next year. It's pretty awesome.
The first thing I learned in Italy: apparently most of my readers are there, and not America. Who knew? This is the first time that I have ever sold out an event, or been ambushed by photographers at the door.
The second thing I learned: even if you're not particularly fond of coffee, it is possible to become addicted to really well-made cappuccinos.
The third thing I learned: that
I cannot recommend five books to anybody.Bizarrely, in the course of 10 interviews in a row on Wednesday alone -- a guaranteed way to lose your grip on reality, incidentally -- I was asked 5 times in succession: "Name 5 books that everyone should own." The first to throw this spanner into my gears was a TV crew from RAI 1, one of the national channels. My response: to stand stunned for a moment and then say,
"Turn off the camera. I need a minute."Eventually, I gave them this response:
"Everybody should have five books that they haven't seen in anybody else's house."I thought that was that, until the next interviewer asked the same question. And the next. And the next. Finally, sitting between translator Nicola Nobili and journalist Stefano Salis at
a public interview in the Giardino di casa Martinia, I was cornered by the (friendly) crowd:
"What five books should every home have?"At first, I responded: "I recommend books to individuals. I can't imagine recommending one book to everybody.... if someone tried that on me,
I'd run in the other direction."
"Thank you for explaining this," one member of the audience said while a translator whispered simultaneously in my ear. "Now, tell us:
what are the five books?"
Uh-oh.
"Ok," I sighed. "I'll give you one.
Three Men in a Boat, by Jerome K Jerome. It's not edifying, and it's not morally or philosophically elevating. But it has the warmth of human presence -- and that is the highest praise I give to a book."
"Thank you," came a response. "
You have four to go."
So I gave them one at a time, though they had to pry them out of me in successive questions: Dodie Smith's
I Capture the Castle, Lee Meriwether's
A Tramp Trip: How to See Europe on 50 Cents a Day,
Religio Medici by Thomas Browne, and Burton's
Anatomy of Melancholy. They were not, I explained, five books for every home, nor were they five books for for all time. They were just five books on my mind
that week.
I'm not sure that I can explain my resistance to issuing a personal canon, but I'm even more bewildered by the desire for one. To, the personal search for books is
at least half the point: and it is utterly dependent on whatever odd cicrumstances, moods, and places happen to converge on any given day. Moreover, my stock of books constantly shifts every time I move house. I reevaluate what each book means to me, and whether I even want to keep it around.
But in retrospect, I suppose the question was really a simpler one, and had little to do with canons at all. At least, I hope so. At its root, it is simply a variation on
"Tell us about yourself."Strangely, for a memoirist, I really have no idea how to answer that question either.